When Everyone Looks Good, Who Gets Remembered?



AI, originality, and the creative judgment we can’t afford to lose
I was listening to a singer recently who had a wonderful voice. Rich, smoky, soulful. The kind of voice that makes you stop what you’re doing and pay attention.
I liked the first song enough to look for more.
And then something happened.
The second song sounded like the first. The third sounded like the second. Before long, I realized I loved her voice, but I wasn’t particularly interested in hearing the same song over and over again.
She had a distinctive sound. But distinctive doesn’t necessarily mean different.
Maybe she’ll expand her repertoire. I hope she does. There’s talent there.
And that got me thinking about advertising, design, and artificial intelligence.
Because something very similar is happening in creative departments.
When Everything Is Beautiful, Nothing Stands Out
AI can create extraordinary images. Perfect lighting, perfect composition, perfect little details.
And increasingly, everything looks like it came from the same creative department.
You’ve seen the look. The charming, Disney-like illustrations. The cinematic lighting. The carefully staged symbolism. The inspirational stacks of books with meaningful titles on their spines.
Everything is lovely.
Everything is polished.
And everything is starting to look familiar.
The danger isn’t that AI will make bad advertising.
The danger is that AI will make millions of beautiful ads nobody notices.
When perfect becomes ordinary, originality becomes extraordinary.
But here’s the interesting part.
People actually like that familiar look.
They’ve learned to love it. They recognize it. They respond to it.
And for a while, that makes it commercially successful.
Until someone does something different.
Then everybody wants that.
And the cycle begins again.
The Next Big Thing Might Be Something Very Old
Remember Barbara Kruger’s bold typography, provocative statements, and striking red, black, and white graphics?
She didn’t invent bold type. She didn’t invent graphic advertising headlines. She borrowed from an existing visual language and used it to communicate something different.
The originality wasn’t necessarily in the ingredients.
It was in what she did with them.
Now imagine someone years from now rediscovering that visual approach, giving it a contemporary twist, and suddenly becoming the inspiration for the next big design trend.
Within months, AI will be producing thousands of variations.
And everyone will be congratulating themselves for looking different.
While looking exactly alike.
That’s the funny thing about trends.
Originality becomes popular. Popularity becomes a trend. The trend becomes a formula. And eventually, the formula becomes invisible.
Which raises an important question.
If we’re all following the same trend, who exactly are we following?
But the Client Asked for It
Throughout my career, clients have come to me with examples of something they’ve seen.
They want that look. That treatment. That style.
And I understand why. Something catches their attention, and naturally they want a little of that magic for themselves.
But rather than simply giving them what they’ve requested, I like to show them three other possibilities.
Not because the trend is necessarily bad.
Because everyone else has already seen it, too.
Why spend money trying to look like your competition when you have an opportunity to stand apart?
A trend tells you what’s getting attention today. Creative direction asks what will still be remembered tomorrow.
That’s a very different assignment.
And it requires something more than the ability to produce an attractive image.
It requires judgment.
The First Idea Is Usually the First Idea
Recently, I was developing an image about originality and standing apart from the crowd.
I asked AI for something unexpected.
It gave me a fish swimming in the opposite direction from all the other fish.
Of course it did.
We’ve all seen that image a thousand times.
So I rejected it.
Next came another clever-looking visual metaphor.
I’d seen that one, too.
Then came rows of identical squares with one different shape.
Better. But still not quite right.
Eventually, I brought in an existing image featuring ordinary paper clips and a paper clip shaped like an airplane.
The paper clips weren’t new.
The airplane wasn’t new.
Even the idea of leaving the crowd wasn’t new.
But I wanted to take that familiar concept somewhere else.
Make all the ordinary paper clips silver. Make the airplane red. Let it fly away from the pile into a beautiful open sky. Let the dull background gradually become brighter as the airplane moves toward the sunlight.
Suddenly, the image wasn’t simply about being different.
It was about the possibilities that open up when you stop following everyone else.
And AI did a wonderful job producing it.
But here’s what I find interesting.
AI didn’t arrive at that solution on its own.
It took direction. Rejection. Revision. Another idea. Another decision.
And that’s not a criticism of the technology.
It’s an illustration of the creative process.
Originality isn’t always inventing something nobody has seen. Sometimes it’s seeing something familiar in a way nobody has thought of.
AI can generate a thousand ideas in seconds.
But it still takes creative judgment to recognize the one worth making.
Where Does That Judgment Come From?
Nobody walks into a creative department on their first day knowing everything.
You learn by doing.
You make mistakes. You get criticized. Sometimes your feelings get hurt. Sometimes someone looks at the idea you spent all night developing and tells you it isn’t working.
And if you’re smart, you listen.
Not necessarily to the tone of the criticism, but to the information buried inside it.
You figure out what went wrong. You try something else. You get better.
Eventually, you begin recognizing problems before anyone points them out.
You develop judgment.
And somewhere along the way, you become the person who can help someone else develop theirs.
That’s how creative departments produce experienced professionals and subject matter experts.
Through experience, mentorship, mistakes, curiosity, and the desire to improve.
Which raises an interesting question.
What happens when we eliminate the people who are supposed to be learning?
The Creative Department With No Future
Imagine a company deciding that AI can handle all the routine creative work.
Why pay junior designers, writers, and production artists when a machine can produce something in seconds?
So the company eliminates those positions.
The senior people remain. They’re experienced. They know what works. They can supervise the AI.
For now.
But who is learning to replace them?
Who is developing the instincts that come from years of solving problems?
Who is becoming tomorrow’s creative director?
Now imagine the company takes the opposite approach.
It eliminates the expensive senior people and keeps a handful of junior employees operating AI tools.
The work gets produced.
But who’s teaching them to recognize when the work is wrong?
Who’s challenging the obvious solution?
Who’s explaining why the beautiful image doesn’t communicate the message?
Either way, something essential disappears.
In one scenario, you eliminate the future experts.
In the other, you eliminate the people who create them.
And eventually, you have a department full of tools and nobody who knows what to do when the tools aren’t enough.
The Fastest Way to Waste Time
Of course, the argument for AI is efficiency.
And sometimes that’s absolutely true.
But there’s a difference between producing something quickly and producing something correctly.
Ask AI to change one small element in an image, and occasionally it will happily change five other things you never asked it to touch.
So you correct those.
And something else changes.
Before long, you’re supervising a very enthusiastic employee who keeps rearranging the furniture every time you ask them to straighten a picture.
At least it attempts the assignment.
We’ve all encountered a human breather who won’t even do that.
But enthusiasm isn’t efficiency.
Neither is speed.
In manufacturing, process improvement is about examining the entire operation, not simply celebrating how quickly one machine completes its part.
Advertising should be no different.
If something takes ten seconds to generate but two hours to correct, verify, rebuild, and approve, was it really a ten-second job?
AI can make mistakes faster than humans can correct them.
And when you factor in the time of an experienced creative director supervising those mistakes, the supposedly inexpensive solution can become surprisingly expensive.
Sometimes, to go fast, you have to go slow.
The Difference Between Starting Over and Learning Something
Imagine a designer working on a project when the computer crashes and the file disappears.
We’ve all had that sinking feeling.
But something remarkable can happen when the designer starts again.
The second version may actually be better.
Why?
Because the designer remembers what worked, what didn’t, what could have been improved, and what they wished they’d tried the first time.
The file is gone.
The experience isn’t.
There’s also something else at work.
Ambition.
The desire to make the next version better than the last.
AI doesn’t have that desire.
It can generate another version. It can respond to instructions. It can even produce something unexpectedly wonderful.
But it doesn’t lie awake thinking about how it could have made the headline stronger.
It doesn’t feel the disappointment of a missed opportunity.
It doesn’t decide that tomorrow it wants to be a better art director.
Humans do.
And that desire to improve is one of the most valuable things a creative department can cultivate.
Don’t Confuse a Finished Image With a Finished Idea
The first idea is often the most obvious idea.
That doesn’t make it useless.
Sometimes it’s the doorway to something better.
You ask yourself why that idea came to mind. What association led you there? What else might communicate the same thought?
You explore.
You challenge.
You get past the obvious.
That’s where interesting work often begins.
But when the first idea arrives beautifully rendered, perfectly typeset, and ready for presentation, there’s an enormous temptation to stop looking.
Why keep exploring when the answer already looks finished?
Because looking finished and being finished are two very different things.
And when thousands of people use similar tools, similar prompts, and similar visual references, the results begin to converge.
The same metaphors.
The same compositions.
The same language.
The same reassuring, polished, perfectly acceptable work.
A world full of perfectly acceptable advertising.
How exciting.
What Are We Actually Trying to Create?
Some of the advertising I remember most vividly wasn’t particularly sophisticated by today’s standards.
A familiar jingle.
A mother calling “Anthony!” from a window.
A simple idea that somehow became part of people’s lives.
Those campaigns didn’t need a thousand visual effects to make an impression.
They needed an idea worth remembering.
And that’s the part of advertising I worry we’re beginning to overlook.
We’re becoming so fascinated with what technology can produce that we sometimes forget to ask what the work is supposed to accomplish.
A beautiful image is not automatically an effective advertisement.
A clever headline is not automatically a meaningful message.
And a finished file is not automatically a finished idea.
AI is an extraordinary tool. I use it. I appreciate what it can do. And I expect it to become considerably better.
But the goal shouldn’t be to replace the thinking that makes creative work valuable.
It should be to give creative people more room to think.
More room to explore.
More room to develop the unexpected idea.
And more opportunity for the next generation to learn how to recognize one.
Because if we eliminate the learning, the mentorship, the mistakes, and the ambition in pursuit of efficiency, we may eventually discover that we’ve automated the very process that made our work distinctive.
We’ll have faster production.
We’ll have beautiful results.
We’ll have more content than anyone could possibly consume.
And we’ll all sound like that talented singer, performing variations of the same song.
The best advertising doesn’t just sell a product. It becomes a memory.
And memories aren’t made by looking like everything else.



Comments