Little Shop of Creative Horrors Starring Artificial Intelligence


What happens when artificial intelligence consumes the very industry that feeds it?
This morning, I discovered something rather amusing while reviewing my website analytics.
Apparently, artificial intelligence has developed quite an appetite for my blog.
Meta AI, Amazon AI, OpenAI, Claude, Perplexity and a number of other automated crawlers have been accessing my website. In the past 30 days alone, my site recorded more than 3,500 automated hits.
The irony, of course, is that many of my recent articles discuss the shortcomings of artificial intelligence.
It immediately brought to mind the movie Little Shop of Horrors.
For those unfamiliar with the story, Seymour discovers an unusual plant that promises him success. All he has to do is feed it. Unfortunately, the more successful Seymour becomes, the greater the plant’s appetite.
Sound familiar?
What began as an amusing discovery this morning led to a rather sad conversation over coffee.
I don’t write these articles for artificial intelligence. I write them for that one art director, that junior art director, or even that seasoned creative who might find something valuable in my years of experience.
I write because someone once invested their time in me.
And now, potentially, the knowledge of people like me is being collected by the very technology that companies are considering using to replace the next generation of us.
Feed me, Seymour.
The Cost of Feeding the Plant
Recently, I spent more than half a day babysitting artificial intelligence on a production assignment.
I deliberately use the word babysitting rather than collaborating.
This was not a subjective creative exercise. It was a project involving architectural specifications where precision was absolutely essential. An error of even a sixteenth of an inch could have consequences.
At one point, artificial intelligence distorted the original artwork to accommodate dimensions rather than preserving the integrity of the design.
It made decisions it had no business making.
Other errors required repeated reviews, corrections and additional verification. In some instances, I found myself correcting problems I had already explained.
Had those errors made their way into fabrication, the financial consequences could have been substantial.
Imagine cutting expensive materials to the wrong specifications. Imagine discovering the mistake during installation. Imagine having to explain to a client why something that had been reviewed and approved didn’t fit.
Who pays for the materials, the labor, the delays and the corrections?
And who pays for the apology?
Certainly not artificial intelligence.
Fortunately, I caught the errors before releasing the corrected files. But consider what it took to recognize those mistakes.
Years of production experience. An understanding of the relationship between design and fabrication. The ability to recognize when something was wrong, even when the computer assured me it was right.
And hours of my time.
The very time artificial intelligence was supposed to save me.
Teaching Versus Babysitting
Throughout my career, I have worked with and mentored younger creatives.
They make mistakes. We all did.
But when I spend an hour explaining to a junior art director why something is wrong, I am doing more than correcting an assignment.
I am investing in their future.
They begin to understand the consequences of their decisions. They develop judgment. They learn to anticipate problems. Eventually, they may catch a mistake before I do.
And someday, they will teach someone else.
That hour has value far beyond the immediate assignment.
When I spend hours correcting artificial intelligence, however, I cannot assume that those corrections will translate into lasting knowledge or improved judgment on the next assignment.
There is an enormous difference between an investment in someone’s education and a recurring expense in supervision.
Yet when companies calculate the financial benefits of artificial intelligence, how often do they account for that difference?
How often do they calculate the cost of an experienced creative director babysitting a machine rather than developing the talents of another human being?
And how often do they calculate the potential cost of a mistake that nobody is experienced enough to recognize?
Feed me, Seymour.
Where Will Tomorrow’s Experts Come From?
The more I think about this, the more concerned I become about the industry’s enthusiasm for eliminating junior positions.
Today’s junior art director is potentially tomorrow’s senior art director, creative director or subject matter expert.
But expertise doesn’t arrive with a promotion or a job title.
It is developed through years of assignments, mistakes, criticism, observation, experimentation and responsibility.
I didn’t acquire my knowledge by simply reading about advertising. I acquired it by doing advertising.
By working with people who knew more than I did. By listening to production specialists. By having ideas rejected. By discovering why something that looked wonderful on paper didn’t necessarily work in the real world.
And sometimes, by making mistakes that I never wanted to make again.
Remove those opportunities and eventually you remove the people capable of supervising the very technology that replaced them.
Meanwhile, artificial intelligence continues collecting the knowledge of those who came before.
We are potentially preserving the knowledge while dismantling the process that creates it.
And therein lies the problem.
What Happens When the Food Runs Out?
Knowledge is not a finite resource that we can simply collect, store and retrieve forever.
It needs to be continually developed.
New problems will emerge. New technologies will develop. New creative challenges will require new thinking.
Artificial intelligence can access an extraordinary amount of existing information. But who will develop the expertise that doesn’t exist yet?
Who will challenge conventional thinking?
Who will discover a better way of doing something through the experience of actually doing it?
Who will write the articles that the next generation of artificial intelligence will crawl?
We are feeding the plant with generations of human knowledge while potentially eliminating the environment in which that knowledge is cultivated.
At what point does the plant begin feeding on itself?
Perhaps We Should Rethink What We’re Feeding
I am not suggesting that artificial intelligence has no place in the creative industry.
It can be an extraordinary resource when used appropriately. In fact, artificial intelligence helped me execute the illustration accompanying this article.
But there is a considerable difference between using artificial intelligence to help execute a creative concept and expecting it to assume the responsibilities of an experienced creative professional.
I question the wisdom of investing so heavily in artificial intelligence while reducing our investment in human intelligence.
The next generation of creatives deserves the opportunity to make mistakes, learn from them, develop their own judgment and eventually contribute something that doesn’t already exist.
Something artificial intelligence hasn’t collected yet.
And if just one junior art director reads this article and recognizes the importance of developing their own expertise, then writing it was worth my time.
As for the artificial intelligence bots visiting my website?
You’re welcome to read along.
But remember what happened to Seymour.
The plant never stopped being hungry.



Comments