top of page
Search

AI Should Help You Express Who You Are—Not Turn You Into Who an Algorithm Thinks You Should Be

Writer: annette steiner
annette steiner
Nov 11
5 min read

Updated: 10 hours ago

Be uniquely you, not just an algorithm approved version of you
Be uniquely you, not just an algorithm approved version of you

I’ve spent most of my career in advertising, where one of the most important things we try to accomplish is making a product or brand stand out from its competition.


So I find it rather ironic that we’re now using artificial intelligence to help us communicate, and in the process, we may be teaching everyone to sound and look alike.


I don’t think that’s what AI should be doing.


AI should help you express who you are. It shouldn’t turn you into who an algorithm thinks you should be.


And there’s a difference.


When Helping Becomes Changing


I recently experienced this while working on my own website.


I was using AI to help optimize my site for search engines. Perfectly reasonable. I want people to find my work, and if technology can help me accomplish that, wonderful.


But as I started reviewing the recommendations, I noticed something.


It wasn’t just helping me make my writing easier to find. It was suggesting changes to the way I expressed myself.


Now, I’ve been writing advertising copy for decades. I know the difference between tightening a sentence to make it communicate more effectively and changing a sentence because someone thinks there’s a more acceptable way to say it.


And I began to wonder, at what point does optimization stop helping you communicate and start changing your personality?


If I follow every recommendation, will my website still sound like me?


Or will it sound like thousands of other websites that followed the same recommendations?


I don’t need AI to tell me who I should be. I need it to help me communicate who I already am.


Not Everything Different Needs to Be Fixed


Think about something as simple as buying eyeglasses.


You can walk into a store and have someone recommend frames based on your face shape, coloring, and whatever happens to be fashionable at the moment.


That’s useful information.


But what if you love a pair of oversized orange glasses?


What if they’re not the frames someone would ordinarily recommend, but they’re exactly what you want?


Should you give them up because some formula says another pair would be more flattering?


Of course not.


The same goes for clothing. Some people love wearing black. Others love color. Some follow fashion trends, while others develop a style that’s entirely their own.


Imagine how boring the world would be if everyone dressed according to the same formula.


Yet that’s essentially what we’re risking when we allow AI to make too many of our creative decisions.


I’ve Seen This Happen in My Own Work


I recently worked on a presentation about growth.


The obvious visual solutions were all there. Trees, seeds, staircases. We’ve all seen them a thousand times.


And there’s nothing inherently wrong with any of those images.


But why would I want to use something everyone has already seen?


Instead, I developed an entirely different concept around a pharmacy, where the various components of a business could be combined into a formula for growth.


Same message. Different way of communicating it.


That’s what creative direction is about.


It’s not simply making something attractive. It’s finding a way to communicate an idea that makes people stop and pay attention.


I’ve also spent a considerable amount of time working with AI-generated imagery. And one of the things I’ve noticed is how often it wants to pull everything toward the same polished, almost Disney-like appearance.


I can give it very specific instructions, ask for something different, correct it, and watch it drift right back toward what it seems to think an image should look like.


Sometimes the results are beautiful.


But beautiful isn’t always the objective.


And sometimes what AI considers an improvement is exactly what I was trying to avoid.


The First Idea Isn’t Always the Best Idea


One of the things I’ve learned over the years is that the first idea that comes to mind is often a cliché.


But that doesn’t mean the first idea is worthless.


I want to know why I thought of it.


What association brought me there? What other connections can I make? Where can I take that thought that someone else hasn’t already gone?


That’s where the interesting ideas begin.


It’s a process of thinking, exploring, rejecting, reconsidering, and sometimes discovering something completely unexpected.


AI can help with that process.


But it can also short-circuit it.


You ask for an idea, and within seconds, it gives you something beautifully written or beautifully illustrated.


It looks finished.


And that’s the danger.


Because when something looks finished, people are much less likely to question whether it was the right idea in the first place.


I’ve always believed that sometimes, to go fast, you have to go slow.


Creative thinking is one of those times.


There’s No Formula for Everything


I’ve said this before, and I’ll probably say it again.


There’s no single formula that works for every problem.


What works for one brand may be completely wrong for another. What works for one person may be completely inappropriate for someone else.


That’s why I believe you have to LEAD: listen before you execute and analyze before you direct.


You have to understand what you’re trying to accomplish before you decide how to accomplish it.


AI is very good at recognizing patterns and suggesting solutions based on those patterns.


But just because something has worked a million times doesn’t mean it’s the right solution for the million-and-first time.


In fact, in advertising, it may be the very reason you shouldn’t use it.


If everyone is doing the same thing, how are you going to stand out?


Who’s Making the Decisions?


I’m not suggesting we stop using AI. I use it regularly, and I find it incredibly valuable.


It helps me research, organize information, explore ideas, and sometimes look at a problem from a perspective I hadn’t considered.


But I don’t accept every recommendation it makes.


I question it. I challenge it. Sometimes I disagree with it completely.


And that’s exactly how I think it should work.


The technology should be there to assist us, not to make every decision for us.


If I ask AI to improve something I’ve written, I want it to help me make my point more clearly. I don’t want it replacing my personality with language it thinks will appeal to the largest number of people.


If I ask it to help develop a visual idea, I want it to explore my concept, not continually steer me back toward the same familiar imagery.


And if I ask it for advice, I want information that helps me make a better decision.


I don’t want it making me into someone else.


The Real Opportunity


We’re living in a time when almost anyone can produce professional-looking writing, illustrations, presentations, and advertising with very little effort.


That’s an extraordinary development.


But if everyone uses the same tools, follows the same recommendations, and accepts the same formulas, we could end up with an enormous amount of perfectly acceptable work that nobody remembers.


And perhaps something even more troubling.


We could lose the very individuality that makes our work, our personalities, and our ideas worth paying attention to.


AI should help us become better at expressing ourselves.


It shouldn’t decide what kind of person, writer, designer, or thinker we ought to be.


Because the objective isn’t to become what an algorithm thinks people want.


It’s to make certain that what people see, hear, and remember is actually you.



 
 
 

Comments


© 2023 by ANNETTE STEINER. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page